I'm probably the king of emotional mistakes. You know those moments when all the clues are right in front of you... and you still somehow reach the wrong conclusion.
This song tells two different stories. In each verse, you see one way of expressing love. Then, in the pre-chorus, the other person expresses love in a completely different way. The problem is... I never recognize those gestures as expressions of love. To me, they're just thoughtful, kind, or sweet. Basically, someone could be saying "I love you" without ever using those words... and I'd be standing there thinking, "Wow... that's really nice of you."
The two stories aren't necessarily about the same relationship. They're simply different examples of the same mistake: expecting love to come back in the exact same way I express it.
It's only at the end that everything clicks. I realize I wasn't lacking love. I was just looking for my own way of expressing it in someone else, instead of learning to recognize theirs.
So this song is probably my biggest emotional fail... but maybe also the most honest thing I've ever written.
---
[VERSE]
The first time you walked me home
I filled the silence word by word
I told you dreams I'd never shared
Said, "You'll be fine," when life got hard
I waited for one line from you
Just one that said you felt it too
You smiled... Then asked if I'd brought my coat.
[PRE-CHORUS]
My coffee waiting by the bed.
My phone already fully charged.
My keys exactly where I'd look.
The porch light always left on.
I'd smile...
"You're really thoughtful..."
Still wishing...
You would've just said it.
[CHORUS]
I gave you every word I had.
Loved you the best way that I knew.
If you felt what I was feeling...
Why didn't it feel the same?
Love shouldn't leave me wondering.
Or crying over what it meant.
If your heart beat anything like mine...
You would've let me know.
[VERSE]
I pictured endings in my head,
The kind that never go to plan.
I swore I'd see the twist come first,
Catch every secret in your hands.
But you just laughed and burned the toast,
Sang off-key to a song you loved.
My script was written for a ghost.
You kept handing me enough.
Every shrug whispered... "I'm trying."
Every flaw said... "I'm still here with you."
[PRE-CHORUS]
Your hand found mine without a word.
You brushed the hair away from my face.
You walked beside the traffic side.
You pulled me closer in the cold.
I'd smile...
"You're such a gentleman..."
Still wishing...
For something more.
[CHORUS]
I gave you every word I had.
Loved you the best way that I knew.
If you felt what I was feeling...
Why didn't it feel the same?
Love shouldn't leave me wondering.
Or crying over what it meant.
If your heart beat anything like mine...
You would've let me know.
[BRIDGE]
"You look beautiful."
A warm cup of coffee.
A handwritten letter.
A hand reaching for mine.
Maybe...
The plot twist was simple.
My heart read in neon.
Yours spoke in margins.
Maybe...
None meant more.
None meant less.
Just...
Another way...
To mean...
Everything.
[FINAL-CHORUS]
You gave me everything you had.
Loved me the best way that you knew.
Every heart has its own voice.
I only listened for my own.
Love was never missing.
Only different.
Every quiet moment...
Every little gesture...
Was the twist I never saw coming.
All the endings I imagined...
Fade out in the morning sun.
You were always there...
Saying it your way.
[OUTRO]
Next time...
I won't ask...
"What does love look like?"
I'll ask...
"How... Does your heart... Show it?"
And wait...
For the answer...
I don't expect.more